Why border-box is a Web Development Best Practice: Paul Irish’s Legacy

Paul Irish popularized Box-sizing: Border-box in 2012 to simplify layout calculations. It includes padding/borders in element dimensions, making responsive design easier. Now a best practice, it’s widely adopted for intuitive, consistent layouts. 🎉

Paul Irish, a well-known web developer and advocate for modern web standards, recommended using the border-box box-sizing model in his 2012 blog post titled “Box-sizing: Border-box is So Much Better.” Here’s why he recommended it, when it gained traction, and why it remains a best practice today:


Why Did Paul Irish Recommend border-box?

Paul Irish advocated for border-box because it simplifies CSS layout calculations and makes it easier to create consistent, predictable designs. Traditionally, the default content-box model calculates an element’s total width and height by adding padding and borders to the specified dimensions. This often leads to unexpected layout issues, especially when working with responsive designs or grid systems.

With border-box, the padding and border are included within the element’s specified width and height, making it easier to manage layouts without constant recalculations. For example:

.box {
box-sizing: border-box; /* Padding and border are included in the element's dimensions */
width: 100%;
padding: 20px;
border: 5px solid black;
}

In this case, the element’s total width remains 100%, including the padding and border, which aligns with how many developers intuitively think about layout sizing.


When Did He Recommend It?

Paul Irish popularized the use of border-box in 2012, a time when responsive design was becoming increasingly important. As developers began building more complex, flexible layouts for a variety of screen sizes, the limitations of the content-box model became more apparent. Irish’s recommendation helped shift the industry toward adopting border-box as a standard practice.


Why Is border-box a Best Practice Today?

  1. Simplifies Layout Calculations
    • With border-box, developers don’t need to manually subtract padding and borders from an element’s width and height, reducing the risk of layout errors.
  2. Improves Responsive Design
    • It ensures that elements behave predictably across different screen sizes, making responsive design more manageable.
  3. Enhances Consistency
    • By including padding and borders within the element’s dimensions, border-box creates a more intuitive and consistent layout experience.
  4. Wide Browser Support
    • border-box is supported in all modern browsers, making it a safe and reliable choice for web development.
  5. Adopted by Modern Frameworks
    • Many CSS frameworks (e.g., Bootstrap) and design systems use border-box as the default box-sizing model, reinforcing its importance.

How to Implement border-box

To make border-box the default for all elements, use this CSS reset:

html {
box-sizing: border-box;
}

*, *::before, *::after {
box-sizing: inherit;
}

This approach ensures consistency across your entire project and aligns with modern best practices.


In summary, Paul Irish recommended border-box because it simplifies layout calculations and improves design consistency. Since his 2012 recommendation, it has become a best practice due to its intuitive behaviour, support for responsive design, and widespread adoption in the web development community.


Posted

in

by

Tags: